Xbox's 25th anniversary gift is a promise, not a game
Wolfenstein 3 and a new id Software project show Xbox leaning on Bethesda's shooter heritage, but with no dates and nine years since the last mainline game, applause can wait.
AI-generated image
What do you give a console brand for its 25th birthday? Xbox's answer was a photo of a script page. It is a charming gift, and we'd argue it is also a revealing one: a company with a lot of studios and not a lot of dates to show for them.
What was actually announced
On Thursday, Xbox CEO Asha Sharma said on X that Wolfenstein 3 is "officially in production" at MachineGames. According to Variety, she called it one of gaming's most important franchises. The reveal came with a script page and a motion-capture photo. Brian Bloom and Debra Wilson return as BJ Blazkowicz and Grace Walker, per Hardwareluxx. The script excerpt points to an interrogation cell, with Fergus and a character named Otto.
The same day, Polygon reports, id Software said its teams in Texas and Frankfurt are working on a new game directed by Hugo Martin, who helmed Doom: The Dark Ages. Release dates and gameplay details for Wolfenstein 3 were not given, and id Software shared very little about its project.
The strategy is sound, and it's the easy part
Betting on Bethesda's shooters is the least risky thing Xbox can do. Wolfenstein has a modern run that began with The New Order in 2014 and continued through The New Colossus in 2017. id has a director with a recent game behind him. Neither needs explaining to anyone. For an anniversary meant to say "we still have great franchises," it's the right drawer to open.
It also makes sense that this was a social media moment rather than a showcase. Cheap to stage, loud on launch day, and it lets Xbox claim the nostalgia without having to ship anything. We think that's smart communications. It isn't the same as smart product planning, and the difference is exactly where the skepticism belongs.
Notice, too, what the one dated item in the package actually is. Polygon notes that a Slaughter Mode update for Doom: The Dark Ages arrives Monday, Nov. 16, free for owners of the Revelations DLC or the premium edition or upgrade. That is the only thing in this wave of news you can really play soon, and it is an extra mode for a game that is already out. Meanwhile, as The Verge notes, Bethesda had just days earlier confirmed that the next Elder Scrolls game will be called The Elder Scrolls VI: Sentinel. Titles are piling up. In our view, titles are not the same as games.
Nine years is a long time to say "trust us"
The gap between The New Colossus and this announcement is nearly a decade. In that time MachineGames made the Youngblood spin-off in 2019 and then Indiana Jones and the Great Circle in 2024. The studio's director, Jerk Gustafsson, had already said the team intended to finish its planned trilogy, as itechpost recounts. Polygon makes the same point, noting the announcement was expected. So "Wolfenstein 3 exists" is less a surprise than a confirmation of something fans were already counting on.
That's why we'd temper the celebration. Polygon itself says both reveals were short on details and that the games are likely still in the early stages of development. A studio that is "in production" and has shared a motion-capture photo can still be years from a trailer, let alone a shelf. A script page proves intent. It doesn't prove a schedule, and after nine years, intent is the least we should expect.
Our verdict
Good news, honestly delivered, but small. Wolfenstein fans have reason to feel optimistic about the creative team and the returning cast. Everyone else should treat both games as entries on a roadmap, not as purchases to plan around. The real test comes when Xbox attaches a platform and a year to these names. Until then, the 25th anniversary gift is a very well-written IOU, and we'd be happy to see it cashed.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Harada is right about the Series S, but wrong about the fix
The Tekken veteran's complaint isn't about one cheap console. It's about a mandatory weaker baseline, and Microsoft should stop treating it as one before the next generation.
Xbox's backward compatibility is the ownership argument PlayStation can't answer
Microsoft joined consoles late and still built the friendliest library for players who want to keep what they paid for. Sony's patchier approach looks weak next to it.
Xbox is a publisher first now, and it's time to judge it that way
Final Fantasy VII Remake Intergrade lands on Game Pass while a 92-rated Xbox game vanishes from the Xbox Store. Both point to the same Xbox: a publisher first.
Blaming Xbox players for E-Day's sales lets Microsoft off the hook
Soft retail numbers for Gears of War: E-Day say more about Game Pass, a crowded calendar and Xbox's platform strategy than about fans who supposedly failed to put money where their mouths are.



