Industry
Gamersfera Newsroom
Industry

Zelnick is right about discs, and that's exactly why you should worry

Take-Two's CEO calls physical games a vinyl-sized niche. It's an honest forecast, but it also hands ownership and resale power from players to platforms.

Published
November 15, 2026
Reading time
3 min
Categories
Industry

Photo: Chris Williams / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

When the boss of the company behind the biggest game of the year says discs will be "a very small part of the business," is he predicting the future or describing a plan? Probably both, and that's the uncomfortable part.

Here is what happened. In an interview with Christopher Dring of The Game Business, Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick said some physical business will always exist, in the way a vinyl business still exists in recorded music, but that it will be a tiny slice. As 3DJuegos reports, 98% of Take-Two's revenue already comes from digital sales, and Zelnick recalled that he predicted over a decade ago that digital would be well above 90% of the business. The timing matters: the same report says GTA 6, due November 19, is sold in stores with a box that holds only a download code.

He's not selling a vision, he's reading a spreadsheet

Credit where it's due: Zelnick isn't spinning. When 98% of your revenue is digital, the disc is a rounding error, and pretending otherwise would be the dishonest move. His earlier remark, that you can't play new games without being connected, is also hard to argue with as a description of how modern launches work.

But notice what an honest forecast does when it comes from the person who sets the strategy. It stops being just a forecast. A publisher that treats the physical edition as a promotional shelf item, a box with a code, has little reason to fight for the format. Forecasts like this one tend to fulfill themselves. That's our reading, not something Zelnick said, but the GTA 6 box is the evidence we'd point to.

The vinyl comparison flatters the disc

Vinyl sounds charming: a loved object, a devoted community. But vinyl survives because the record is still the music. A box with a code is not the game. It's a receipt in cardboard, and the thing you actually own is a license inside someone else's store.

That's where the real cost lands. Lending a game, trading it in, selling it secondhand: laverdadnoticias notes that some players value exactly those abilities, plus keeping their games independent of digital storefronts. Every one of those freedoms depends on a physical object that works on its own. Once the disc becomes a collector's curiosity, those freedoms become a niche too. In our view, the loser here isn't nostalgia. It's the used market and anyone who wants a game to still be playable if a storefront changes its terms.

What disc buyers should actually do

Read Zelnick as a warning, not a weather report. We'd suggest three habits. Buy the physical edition when a real disc exists, especially for games you expect to keep for years. Don't confuse a code-in-a-box with a physical purchase; check what's actually inside before you pay a retail price for it. And make noise: the disc isn't dying of natural causes, it's being deprioritized by people with a financial reason to do so.

To be fair, there's a counterargument. Many players will happily trade ownership for convenience, and digital sales do bring instant access. That's a legitimate choice. The problem is when it stops being a choice.

Zelnick is right that discs will shrink. Whether they shrink into a respected niche or vanish into a footnote depends on whether buyers keep asking for them. If the biggest launch of the year has no disc, the rest of the industry is watching to see whether anyone cares. We think players should make sure they do.

Debate topics

No topics yet: start the first one.

More stories